The best free Instagram comment picker
For a free Instagram giveaway draw, Perkadoo's comment picker takes the most comments: up to 10,000, with no account, no ads and no paywall. It checks tagged friends, words and hashtags, then gives a results page anyone can verify. As of October 2026, Comment Picker's free tier stops at 100 comments, and Simpliers' and Gleam's at 200.
Updated
Free Instagram comment pickers compared
What each picker does before you pay, then what paying costs.
| Free tier | Paid from | |
|---|---|---|
| Perkadoo | Up to 10,000 comments and 100 winners. Up to 5 required tags, a word or hashtag, excluded accounts. No ads, no account. | Nothing to pay to pick. A hosted giveaway page is a one-off $19. |
| Comment Picker | Up to 100 comments on 1 post, 1 winner, no entry filters. Shows ads. | Premium: $9.99/month or $95.91/year, unlimited comments, up to 10 winners. |
| Simpliers | Up to 200 entries and 1 pick per post. Loads comments from a public post's link. | $19.90/month, or $9.99/month billed yearly, up to 40,000 entries. |
| Gleam | Up to 200 comments. | $3.99 per post for up to 1,000 comments. |
| Easypromos | Set up your first Instagram giveaway free. You pay when you publish it. | Basic: $29/month before VAT, up to 5,000 comments in a draw. |
Sources, checked 2026-10-16: Comment Picker Instagram tool, Comment Picker Premium, Simpliers pricing, Gleam Instagram comment picker, Easypromos pricing
Pick another tool if
- You'd rather paste a post link than copy the comments. Simpliers and Easypromos load them for you; Perkadoo takes a paste or a CSV.
- One giveaway runs across several posts or Reels. Easypromos imports up to 25, and Comment Picker Premium draws across posts.
- You filter by likes or comment date. That's in Comment Picker Premium; Perkadoo filters by tags, words and excluded accounts.
- Your post has more than 10,000 comments. Simpliers' paid plan takes up to 40,000 entries.
- You want follow checks or a minimum follower count as entry rules. Simpliers offers those.
What a free picker has to get right
Every comment counts
A cap of 100 or 200 means a busy post gets drawn from a slice of its entries, and the people left out never know. Check the cap against your comment count before you trust the result.
Your caption's rules, applied first
If the caption said "tag 2 friends", the picker should drop comments with fewer tags, and self-tags or tags of your own account shouldn't count. You see the eligible list before anything is drawn.
Proof entrants can check
Perkadoo locks the list, then draws with public drand randomness published after the lock. The results page shows the list fingerprint and the drand round, so anyone can rerun the pick.
Backups in the same draw
Winners don't always reply. Draw a couple of backup names at the same time so the next one is already fair and on record.
Pick your Instagram winner free
Run giveaways that bring people back
Save one draw free. Host giveaways from $24/month or $19 for one.
Questions people ask
What is the best free Instagram comment picker?
For big posts, Perkadoo: as of October 2026 it takes up to 10,000 comments and 100 winners free, where Comment Picker's free tier allows 100 comments and Simpliers' 200 entries. If you need multi-post draws or like filters, Comment Picker Premium at $9.99/month does those.
Do I need to log in to Instagram to pick a winner?
No. Perkadoo never asks for your Instagram password. Load all the comments on your post in a desktop browser, copy and paste them in, or upload a CSV.
Is a free comment picker fair enough for a real giveaway?
Yes, if it draws from every valid entry and you can show how. Post the results link under your winner announcement so entrants can check the draw themselves.